Elsevier

Toxicology Letters

Volume 230, Issue 2, 15 October 2014, Pages 104-121
Toxicology Letters

A systematic review of neurodevelopmental effects of prenatal and postnatal organophosphate pesticide exposure

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.toxlet.2013.11.019Get rights and content

Highlights

  • This review studied the effects of OP pesticide exposure on child neurodevelopment.

  • Prenatal exposure was associated with negative effects on child mental development.

  • Evidence on postnatal exposure effects on child neurodevelopment is less consistent.

  • The high variability of methodologies across studies made comparisons difficult.

  • Standardised methodologies are needed to perform quantitative meta-analysis.

Abstract

Agricultural and residential use of organophosphate (OP) pesticides has increased in recent decades after banning some persistent pesticides. Although there is evidence of the effects of OPs on neurodevelopment and behaviour in adults, limited information is available about their effects in children, who might be more vulnerable to neurotoxic compounds. This paper was aimed at analysing the scientific evidence published to date on potential neurodevelopmental and behavioural effects of prenatal and postnatal exposure to OPs. A systematic review was undertaken to identify original articles published up to December 2012 evaluating prenatal or postnatal exposure to OPs in children and effects on neurodevelopment and/or behaviour. Articles were critically compared, focusing on the methodology used to assess exposure and adverse effects, as well as potential contributing factors that may modify both exposure and outcomes, such as genetic susceptibility to certain enzymes involved in OPs metabolisation (e.g. paraoxonase-1) and gender differences. Twenty articles met the inclusion criteria, 7 of which evaluated prenatal exposure to OPs, 8 postnatal exposure and 5 both pre- and postnatal exposure. Most of the studies evaluating prenatal exposure observed a negative effect on mental development and an increase in attention problems in preschool and school children. The evidence on postnatal exposure is less consistent, although 2 studies found an increase in reaction time in schoolchildren. Some paraoxonase-1 polymorphisms could enhance the association between OPs exposure and mental and psychomotor development. A large variability in epidemiological designs and methodologies used for assessing exposure and outcome was observed across the different studies, which made comparisons difficult. Prenatal and to a lesser extent postnatal exposure to OPs may contribute to neurodevelopmental and behavioural deficits in preschool and school children. Standardised methodologies are needed to allow results to be better compared and to perform a quantitative meta-analysis before drawing any final conclusions.

Introduction

Earlier restrictions on the use of some persistent pesticides have led to the use of non-persistent alternatives such as organophosphates (OPs), carbamates and pyrethroids, which are very useful for controlling pests in both agricultural and residential settings. Intensive use of these compounds is posing a significant risk to public health because of their potential adverse effects. Exposure to pesticides does not only affect those who use them occupationally, as the general population is also exposed to low concentrations through foodstuffs and the environment throughout their lifetime. There is scientific evidence of the carcinogenic, neurological, reproductive, immunological and genotoxic effects associated with exposure to non-persistent pesticides in adults (Koureas et al., 2012). However, little information is available about the effects in children, although researchers have observed a higher risk of adverse reproductive effects (Eskenazi et al., 2004, Lacasaña et al., 2006, Rauch et al., 2012) and changes in the nervous system and in neurobehavioural development (Bouchard et al., 2010, Engel et al., 2011, Eskenazi et al., 2007, Marks et al., 2010, Rauh et al., 2012). This means that the neurotoxic effects of these compounds on children's central nervous systems could be causing a series of subclinical neurodevelopmental disorders. This has been termed a ‘silent pandemic’ and could have major health, economic and social impact (Grandjean and Landrigan, 2006).

Toxicological studies in animals have provided information about the neurotoxicity mechanisms and adverse effects of non-persistent pesticides. For example, Maurissen (2000) and Rice and Barone (2000) observed changes in the nervous system development and sensory, motor and cognitive cerebral function of rodents associated with prenatal and early postnatal exposure to chlorpyrifos. Prenatal exposure even to low concentrations of chlorpyrifos also affects rodents’ organogenesis (Tian et al., 2005) and leads to behavioural changes such as hyperactivity and working and reference memory deficit.

Factors such as age, sex, nutritional status, lifestyle and genetic variability can modify the effects of non-persistent pesticides in children, who are particularly susceptible to these compounds. The health risks derived from exposure to toxic agents are strongly influenced by genetics as a result of the variability of the genes that code for metabolising enzymes (Costa et al., 2003, Eaton et al., 1998, Furlong, 2007). The different possible combinations of these polymorphisms can determine favourable or unfavourable metabolic configurations, either facilitating the breakdown of some neurotoxic compounds, or bioactivating initially inactive compounds or delaying the metabolic breakdown of active compounds (Costa et al., 2005a, Costa et al., 2005b, Guo et al., 2012). Recent studies have analysed the effect of different paraoxonase-1 (PON1) polymorphisms on neurodevelopment in children. Certain genotypes (PON1–108TT, PON1192QR and PON1192RR) may be associated with reduced mental and motor development in children exposed to OP pesticides (Engel et al., 2011, Eskenazi et al., 2010).

The limited number of epidemiological studies available and the huge variability of the methodologies used to assess exposure to OP pesticides and its effects on neurodevelopment in children make it difficult to compare their results. The aim of this review is to carry out a detailed analysis of the evidence gathered in the studies performed to date, taking into account some of the factors that can modify the effects of these pesticides, such as sex and gender differences, genetic variability and epigenetic factors. This will provide a better overview of the relationship between exposure to OP pesticides and neurodevelopment and behaviour in children.

Section snippets

Search strategy

A systematic review of articles in the PubMed, Scopus, Embase and Lilacs databases was carried out using the following key words or text word combinations: “organophosphates” OR “organophosphorus”, “child” OR “infant”, “neurodevelopment”, “neurobehavioral” OR “neurobehavioural” (for more details see Supplemental Material, annex I).

Inclusion and exclusion criteria

The articles selected for the review met the following inclusion criteria: (a) original articles; (b) published before or during December 2012; (c) written in

Results

134 articles were identified using the search strategy described above. Twenty of those met the inclusion criteria, 7 of which analysed prenatal exposure to OP pesticides, 8 analysed postnatal exposure, and 5 analysed both pre- and postnatal exposure. Cohort studies were the most frequent design (n = 10), followed by cross-sectional (n = 9) and case-control (n = 1) studies. The methodological quality of studies on prenatal exposure was high (n = 9) or moderate (n = 3), while that of studies on postnatal

Effects potentially associated with prenatal and postnatal exposure to OPs

The results of the aforementioned studies suggest that prenatal exposure to OP pesticides may affect neurodevelopment and behaviour in infancy and childhood as well as children's cognitive and motor function.

The average maternal urinary DAPs in the studies reviewed ranged from 81.3 nmol/L (Engel et al., 2007) to 132 nmol/L (Young et al., 2005). These levels are slightly higher than those found in the pregnant women who took part in the National Health and Nutrition Survey 1999–2000 (NHANES),

Conclusions

The studies included in this review used a wide variety of different designs and methods to evaluate the effects of OP pesticide exposure on neurodevelopment and behaviour in children, and this makes it difficult to compare their results. The studies reviewed suggest that exposure during pregnancy may have a negative effect on the child's mental and motor development and behaviour during the first stages of childhood. The effects associated with postnatal exposure are less consistent, although

Conflict of interest

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest.

Acknowledgements

This study was partially supported by grants from the Council of Innovation of the Andalusian Government (reference number P08-CTS-04313, FEDER funds), the Institute of Health Carlos III (reference numbers PI10/01101 and FIS-FEDER 11/02038) and the European Union (EU FP7-ENV-2011 DENAMIC 2cod 28957).

The content of this article is part of the PhD thesis of Beatriz Gonzalez-Alzaga which was conducted at the University of Granada under the doctoral programme “Clinical Medicine and Public Health”.

References (98)

  • W. Griffith et al.

    Organophosphate pesticide metabolite levels in pre-school children in an agricultural community: within- and between-child variability in a longitudinal study

    Environ. Res.

    (2011)
  • Y. Guo et al.

    Identification of two new cytochrome P450 genes and RNA interference to evaluate their roles in detoxification of commonly used insecticides in Locusta migratoria

    Chemosphere

    (2012)
  • M.K. Horton et al.

    Does the home environment and the sex of the child modify the adverse effects of prenatal exposure to chlorpyrifos on child working memory?

    Neurotoxicol. Teratol.

    (2012)
  • W. Jedrychowski et al.

    Gender specific differences in neurodevelopmental effects of prenatal exposure to very low-lead levels: the prospective cohort study in three-year olds

    Early Hum. Dev.

    (2009)
  • M. Koureas et al.

    Systematic review of biomonitoring studies to determine the association between exposure to organophosphorus and pyrethroid insecticides and human health outcomes

    Toxicol. Lett.

    (2012)
  • M. Olmos et al.

    Systematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies on the prevalence of fractures in coeliac disease

    Dig. Liver Dis.

    (2008)
  • F. Perera et al.

    Prenatal environmental exposures, epigenetics, and disease

    Reprod. Toxicol.

    (2011)
  • A.M. Persico et al.

    Searching for ways out of the autism maze: genetic, epigenetic and environmental clues

    Trends Neurosci.

    (2006)
  • C. Pope et al.

    Pharmacology and toxicology of cholinesterase inhibitors: uses and misuses of a common mechanism of action

    Environ. Toxicol. Pharmacol.

    (2005)
  • M. Rodríguez-Barranco et al.

    Association of arsenic, cadmium and manganese exposure with neurodevelopment and behavioural disorders in children: A systematic review and meta-analysis

    Sci. Total Environ.

    (2013)
  • D.S. Rohlman et al.

    Neurobehavioral performance in preschool children from agricultural and non-agricultural communities in Oregon and North Carolina

    Neurotoxicology

    (2005)
  • R.A. Schuh et al.

    Noncholinesterase mechanism of chlorpyrifos neurotoxicity: altered phosphorylation of Ca2+/cAMP response element binding protein in cultured neurons

    Toxicol. Appl. Pharmacol.

    (2002)
  • Y. Tian et al.

    Teratogenicity and developmental toxicity of chlorpyrifos. Maternal exposure during organogenesis in mice

    Reprod. Toxicol.

    (2005)
  • A.M. Tsatsakis et al.

    Determination of dialkyl phosphates in human hair for the biomonitoring of exposure to organophosphate pesticides

    J. Chromatogr.

    (2010)
  • P.D. Varga-Weisz et al.

    Regulation of higher-order chromatin structures by nucleosome-remodelling factors

    Curr. Opin. Genet. Dev.

    (2006)
  • E. von Elm et al.

    STROBE initiative the strengthening the reporting of observational studies in epidemiology (STROBE) statement: guidelines for reporting observational studies

    J. Clin. Epidemiol.

    (2008)
  • J.G. Young et al.

    Association between in utero organophosphate pesticide exposure and abnormal reflexes in neonates

    Neurotoxicology

    (2005)
  • X. Zhang et al.

    Genome wide study of DNA methylation alterations in response to diazinon exposure in vitro

    Environ. Toxicol. Pharmacol.

    (2012)
  • T.M. Achenbach et al.

    Manual for the ASEBA Preschool Forms and Profiles

    (2000)
  • C. Aprea et al.

    Biologic monitoring of exposure to organophosphorus pesticides in 195 italian children

    Environ. Health Perspect.

    (2000)
  • D.B. Barr et al.

    Concentrations of dialkyl phosphate metabolites of organophosphorus pesticides in the U.S. population

    Environ. Health Perspect.

    (2004)
  • C.F. Bearer et al.

    Ethyl linoleate in meconium: a biomarker of prenatal ethanol exposure

    Alcohol Clin. Exp. Res.

    (1999)
  • A. Bird

    DNA methylation patterns and epigenetic memory

    Genes Dev.

    (2002)
  • M.F. Bouchard et al.

    Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and urinary metabolites of organophosphate pesticides

    Pediatrics

    (2010)
  • M.F. Bouchard et al.

    Prenatal exposure to organophosphate pesticides and IQ in 7-year-old children

    Environ. Health Perspect.

    (2011)
  • A. Bradman et al.

    Organophosphate urinary metabolite levels during pregnancy and after delivery in women living in an agricultural community

    Environ. Health Perspect.

    (2005)
  • P. Cheung et al.

    Epigenetic regulation by histone methylation and histone variants

    Mol. Endocrinol.

    (2005)
  • J.E. Clougherty

    A growing role for gender analysis in air pollution epidemiology

    Environ. Health Perspect.

    (2010)
  • L.G. Costa et al.

    Paraoxonase (PON 1) as a biomarker of susceptibility for organophosphate toxicity

    Biomarkers

    (2003)
  • J.F. Costello et al.

    Methylation matters

    J. Med. Genet.

    (2001)
  • C.L. Curl et al.

    Evaluation of take-home organophosphorus pesticide exposure among agricultural workers and their children

    Environ. Health Perspect.

    (2002)
  • C.L. Curl et al.

    Organophosphorus pesticide exposure of urban and suburban preschool children with organic and conventional diets

    Environ. Health Perspect.

    (2003)
  • D.L. Eaton et al.

    Genetic susceptibility

  • S.M. Engel et al.

    Prenatal organophosphate metabolite and organochlorine levels and performance on the Brazelton Neonatal Behavioral Assessment Scale in a multiethnic pregnancy cohort

    Am. J. Epidemiol.

    (2007)
  • S.M. Engel et al.

    Prenatal exposure to organophosphates, paraoxonase 1, and cognitive development in childhood

    Environ. Health Perspect.

    (2011)
  • B. Eskenazi et al.

    Association of in utero organophosphate pesticide exposure and fetal growth and length of gestation in an agricultural population

    Environ. Health Perspect.

    (2004)
  • B. Eskenazi et al.

    PON1 and neurodevelopment in children from the CHAMACOS study exposed to organophosphate pesticides in utero

    Environ. Health Perspect.

    (2010)
  • B. Eskenazi et al.

    Organophosphate pesticide exposure and neurodevelopment in young Mexican-American children

    Environ. Health Perspect.

    (2007)
  • W. Filipowicz et al.

    Mechanisms of post-transcriptional regulation by microRNAs: are the answers in sight

    Nat. Rev. Genet.

    (2008)
  • Cited by (164)

    • Pesticide analytical screening system (PASS): A novel electrochemical system for multiplex screening of glyphosate and chlorpyrifos in high-fat and low-fat food matrices

      2023, Food Chemistry
      Citation Excerpt :

      There is an increased desire for a portable, field-applicable detection system due to the prevalence of pesticide usage and the increasing numbers of people who are potentially ingesting toxic chemicals. Extensive prior pre-processing of samples as well as requiring laboratory equipment is not only an expensive undertaking for farmers or regulatory agencies but generally has heightened error due to their long experimental procedures (Gilbert-López et al., 2009; González-Alzaga et al., 2014; Guan et al., 2009; Wilkowska & Biziuk, 2011). Farmers or normal consumers wishing to track pesticide levels generally don’t have scientific expertise and the current options on the market require stringent pre-processing as well as technical knowledge regarding several experimental procedures.

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text