Have children adapted to their mothers working, or was adaptation unnecessary? Cohort effects and the relationship between maternal employment and child well-being
Highlights
► We study if maternal employment effects on child well-being vary by birth cohorts. ► Regardless of birth cohort, we find maternal employment is mostly inconsequential. ► Children from earlier cohorts show positive effects of having an employed mother. ► These beneficial effects appear to have disappeared in recent cohorts.
Introduction
One of the most prominent demographic trends in contemporary family life is the rate at which American women have entered the paid labor force over the past several decades (Bianchi, 2000). In fact, the most recent data suggest that women now stand to outnumber men in the work force if current recessionary trends continue with men experiencing unemployment at a higher rate than women (Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2009). Even though women’s employment is a normative feature of contemporary families, controversy continues to surround the issue, with special attention given to mothers’ employment. Maternal labor force participation is still scrutinized and questioned in the popular media, and child outcomes are often placed at the center of these debates out of concern over the consequences of maternal absence from the home (Hirshman, 2006, Sayer et al., 2004).
Even scholarly research frequently approaches the issue of maternal employment from what Gottfried and Gottfried (2006) call a deprivation perspective, where researchers search for negative outcomes related to mothers’ labor force participation without placing this family process within a sufficiently broader context. In this study, we place maternal employment and its potential influences on child well-being within such a broader context—in this case, the context of birth cohorts. The contemporary milieu of maternal employment is different than it was decades ago. For instance, child care now is more readily available and arguably of higher quality, cultural attitudes about women’s work roles have become less traditional as women have established rewarding and successful careers, and fathers have assumed more active parenting responsibilities within families. Therefore, children born in more recent cohorts likely experience their mothers’ labor force participation differently than children born in earlier cohorts did, and we suspect that this effect of historical time is consequential for children’s developmental trajectories.
By contextualizing child outcomes associated with maternal employment within birth cohorts, we seek to reconcile some of the mixed findings so common within the maternal employment and child well-being literature. Especially when negative effects of maternal employment are documented using data from the 1979 National Longitudinal Survey of Youth (NLSY79), researchers tend to rely on subgroup analyses and restricted samples—for instance, only examining White children (Waldfogel et al., 2002) or 10 and 11 year olds (Ruhm, 2008)—and an inconsistent array of categorical measures of maternal work hours (cf. Burchinal and Clarke-Stewart, 2007). In contrast, we conduct longitudinal analyses using a fully inclusive sample from the NLSY79 that permit us to correctly account for age and timing effects associated with comprehensive measures of maternal employment as we investigate cohort differences. As such, a focus on birth cohorts, in addition to being theoretically and empirically justified, requires us to use analytic techniques that allow us to avoid many of the shortcomings of previous research in this area.
Section snippets
Background
The majority of American women—wives and mothers—are employed. About 60% of all women over age 16 and over 70% of mothers are currently employed, compared to just 42% and 47% respectively in 1975 (Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2006, Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2007). Wives’ contributions to total family household income grew from a median of about 27% in 1970 to 35% in 2004, and now about 25% of married women out-earn their employed husbands, compared to just 18% in 1987. These changes in women’s
Sample
The sample data for this study are drawn from the Children of the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth 1979 (C-NLSY79), which is sponsored by the US Bureau of Labor Statistics and the National Institute for Child Health and Human Development. This data set is among the most popular for examining maternal employment and child outcomes (Lucas-Thompson et al., 2010). The C-NLSY79, which started in 1986 and continues on a biennial schedule, is comprised of all children born to the 6283 original
Descriptives
Table 1 displays overall means and standard deviations by birth cohort for all variables used in the growth curve analyses. A brief examination of these descriptive statistics indicates important differences in mean scores for some key variables across the five birth cohorts identified in this study. First, ignoring all other variables (including age), mean values for reading scores and math scores do not appear to vary in a predictable manner across all five cohorts; however, children in more
Discussion and conclusion
The context of maternal employment certainly has changed over the past several decades. Child care arrangements are more abundant, fathers are more involved in family life, women are benefitting from the financial and psychological rewards that come from having a career, and cultural attitudes about maternal employment are more supportive. These trends suggest that adaptations have been made to maternal employment as a normative feature of contemporary families. Our investigation of cohort
References (74)
- et al.
Maternal employment and adolescent risky behavior
Journal of Health Economics
(2004) - et al.
First-year maternal employment and child outcomes: differences across racial and ethnic groups
Children and Youth Services Review
(2008) - et al.
The transformation of US gender role attitudes: cohort replacement, social-structural change, and ideological learning
Social Science Research
(2004) - et al.
The detailed age trajectories of oral vocabulary knowledge: differences by class and race
Social Science Research
(2004) Policies to foster human capital
Research in Economics
(2000)The effects of religion on the labor supply of married women
Social Science Research
(1995)- et al.
Identification of a Flynn effect in the NLSY: moving from the center to the boundaries
Intelligence
(2007) Maternal employment and adolescent development
Labour Economics
(2008)- et al.
Paid employment and women’s health: a benefit or a source of role strain
Sociology of Health and Illness
(1985) Does early maternal employment harm child development? An analysis of the potential benefits of leave taking
Journal of Labor Economics
(2003)
The long-term effects of early and recent maternal employment on a child’s academic achievement
Journal of Family Issues
Early and extensive maternal employment and young children’s socioemotional development: children of the national longitudinal survey of youth
Journal of Marriage and the Family
Maternity leave, early maternal employment, and child health and development in the US
The Economic Journal
The effect of maternal employment and child care on children’s cognitive development
International Economic Review
Maternal employment and time with children: dramatic change or surprising continuity
Demography
Maternal labor supply and children’s cognitive development
The Review of Economics and Statistics
Feminist attitudes and support for gender equality: opinion change in women and men, 1974–1998
Social Forces
The normative development of child and adolescent problem behavior
Journal of Abnormal Psychology
The relation of infants’ home environments to mental test performance at fifty-four months: a follow-up study
Child Development
The relation of home environment, cognitive competence, and IQ among males and females
Child Development
The relation of infants’ home environments to achievement test performance in first grade: a follow-up study
Child Development
Testing social learning theory using reinforcement’s residue: a multilevel analysis of self-reported theft and marijuana use in the national youth survey
Criminology
Maternal employment and child cognitive outcomes: the importance of analytic approach
Developmental Psychology
NLSY79 Child & Young Adult Data User’s Guide
Romantic partners’ influence on men’s likelihood of arrest in early adulthood
Criminology
Children of the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth: a unique research opportunity
Developmental Psychology
Trajectories of parenting processes and adolescent substance use: reciprocal effects
Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology
Perception of child, child-rearing values, and emotional distress as mediating links between environmental stresses and observed maternal behavior
Child Development
Life-course effects of work and family circumstances on children
Social Forces
Adolescent gender ideology socialization: direct and moderating effects of fathers’ beliefs
Sociological Spectrum
Mother or market? Effects of maternal employment on the intellectual ability of 4-year-old children
Demography
Peabody Individual Achievement Test Manual
Households, Employment, and Gender: A Social, Economic, and Demographic View
Cohort analysts’ futile quest: statistical attempts to separate age, period and cohort effects
American Sociological Review
Maternal employment and children’s achievement in context: a meta-analysis of four decades of research
Psychological Bulletin
Cited by (8)
Let’s Read the Story Again: An Insight into Employed and Unemployed Mother’s Interactions After Story Reading
2023, Asia-Pacific Journal of Research in Early Childhood EducationThe mediating role of family and food-related life satisfaction in the relationships between family support, parent work-life balance and adolescent life satisfaction in dual-earner families
2018, International Journal of Environmental Research and Public HealthBlame Their Mothers: Public Opinion About Maternal Employment as a Cause of Juvenile Delinquency
2017, Feminist CriminologyMaternal Working Hours and the Well-Being of Adolescent Children: Evidence from British Data
2016, Journal of Family and Economic Issues