How much does social capital add to individual health?A survey study of Russians
Section snippets
Applying social capital theories to health
Generically, capital is a stock of resources used to produce goods and services. Manufacturing and financial capital are central in economic analysis. Natural resource capital, such as the stock of oil and minerals, is a second important form of capital. Human capital describes an individual’s productive resources, for example, education. Conventional economic analysis has yet to give recognition to the concept of social capital, but arguments are increasingly made that it is a distinctive
Russian evidence
The Soviet Union’s record in health was positive — up to a point. Although Soviet health statistics raise many questions of validity and interpretation (see e.g. Meslé et al., 1992, Lutz et al., 1994; Part III), in the first decades after 1945 life expectancy undoubtedly rose and infant mortality fell greatly. But by 1965 progress was slowing down and evidence of a deterioration in health began to emerge. Between 1965 and 1985 the reported life expectancy of female Russians rose by only 1.2
Analyzing the evidence
Classic OLS multiple regression is appropriate for testing how much or how little support hypothesized influences have, net of other influences on physical and emotional health, each assessed on five-point scales. Having multiple indicators of human and of social capital makes it possible to identify which specific forms have a strong influence on Russian health — and which do not. Three regression models are presented for physical and for emotional health. The first tests Hypothesis 1,
Implications
To determine how much human and social capital influence health, we must turn to the unstandardized coefficient (b), which estimates how much change in health occurs as the result of one unit of change in an independent variable. Significant influences are, except for gender, ordinal or continuous variables, but their scales differ in length from rouble income to the four-point scale measuring trust in other people (for details, see Appendix A). Therefore, impact is here shown by calculating
Acknowledgements
This paper is part of a project on Coping with Organizations: Networks of Russian Social Capital, financed by the Leverhulme Trust, London. The survey data were collected with help from a grant to the World Bank Social Capital Initiative, from the development fund of the Danish government. I am indebted to Professor Sir Michael Marmot, Professor Martin McKee and Dr. Martin Bobak for encouraging my interest in the health of Russians, and to Ismail Serageldin and Christian Grootaert of the World
References (43)
- et al.
Socioeconomic factors, perceived control and self-reported health in Russia
Social Science & Medicine
(1998) - et al.
The role of social capital in the Russian mortality crisis
World Development
(1998) Explaining rising mortality among men in Eastern Europe
Social Science & Medicine
(1995)Health and social change in Russia and Eastern Europe
(1999)Foundations of social theory
(1990)Trust as a commodity
The organization and performance of the contemporary Soviet health service
Suicide: a study in sociology
(1995)Russia: too sick to matter?
Policy Review
(1999)