Regional socioeconomic differences in mortality among men in Great Britain today

doi:10.1016/S0033-3506(88)80008-8

Public Health

Volume 102, Issue 1, January 1988, Pages 33-43

https://doi.org/10.1016/S0033-3506(88)80008-8 Get rights and content

Regional socioeconomic differences in mortality among men aged 20–64 years were studied using data from the Decennial Supplement on Occupational Mortality based on the 1981 census. In our analysis deaths from all causes showed an increasing gradient from the south-east to the north-west of the country with the highest levels in Scotland (SMR 123). The regional gradient for all causes was steeper in the manual workers than in the non-manual workers. The Scottish manual workers showed levels of mortality (SMR 146) twice that of non-manual workers (SMR 73) in the south-east of England. Excess deaths from ischaemic heart disease and stroke were confined to manual workers, with the highest levels in Scotland (SMRs 145 and 161 respectively). Deaths from cancer showed an increasing gradient from the south-east to the north-west with somewhat similar levels in Scotland (SMR 113) and the north-west of England (SMR 116). Mortality levels of lung cancer among manual workers in the north-west of England (SMR 158) and Scotland (SMR 156) were twice those prevalent among non-manual workers in these areas. Scottish men, both manual (SMR 241) and non-manual (SMR 174) suffered from excess deaths attributed to cirrhosis of the liver. Deaths from motor vehicle accidents (SMR 163) and suicide (SMR 146) were significantly raised only among the Scottish manual workers.

References (24)

MonsonR.R.
Cigarette smoking and body form in peptic ulcer
Gastroenterology
(1970)
ArmstrongB.K. et al.
Commodity consumption and ischaemic heart disease mortality with special reference to dietary practices
Journal of Chronic Diseases
(1975)
General Register Office
Registrar General Scotland
Occupational mortality 1969–73
(1981)
Office of Population Censuses and Surveys
Occupational mortality Decennial Supplement. England and Wales 1970–72
(1978)
Office of Population Censuses and Surveys
Occupational mortality Decennial Supplement. England and Wales 1979–80, 82–83
(1986)
McDowallM.
William Farr and the study of occupational mortality
BalarajanR. et al.
British smoking and drinking habits: regional variations
Community Medicine
(1986)
DollR.
Atmospheric pollution and lung cancer
Environmental Health Perspectives
(1978)
FribergL. et al.
Late effects of air pollution with special reference to Lung Cancer
Environmental Health Perspectives
(1978)
FraumeniJ.F. et al.
Lung and Pleura

ColeP. et al.

Smoking and cancer of the lower urinary tract

New England Journal of Medicine

(1971)

DollR. et al.

Mortality in relation to smoking: 20 years' observations on male British doctors

British Medical Journal

(1976)

Cited by (15)

Regional assessment of elderly disability in the U.S.
2000, Social Science and Medicine
Citation Excerpt :
Furthermore, this purported pattern may be complicated by migration patterns (Greenberg and Schneider 1992), as Blacks and Whites followed quite different paths during the so-called greater migration period — 1920 to 1970 (Grossman, 1989). However, physical and man-made environments may have an effect on disability risk, independent of individuals' socioeconomic characteristics (Balarajan and McDowall, 1988; Pope and Tarlow, 1991). It is believed that geographic patterning of risk factors are inculcated in historical, cultural, physical and socioeconomic environments.
This study examines regional variation of elderly disability in the United States. Elderly disability measurements are derived from two newly available questions on mobility and self-care limitations in the 1990 census. Substantial regional differences in elderly disability rates exist, with a higher prevalence of disability in the Southeast. These differences persist after controlling for age and socioeconomic status (SES). The study findings suggest that some public health policy should be regionally formulated and some government actions should be devoted to reduce the excessive elderly disability in the South.
The ethics of attribution: The case of health care outcome indicators
1998, Social Science and Medicine
The ethical basis of clinical outcomes measurement is a desire to improve care in a way which will increase both clinical effectiveness and value for money—beneficence as well as competence. To date in the U.K., any debate about producing comparative indicators of clinical outcomes has been concerned mainly with the unfairness to individual doctors or clinical teams of judging their performance on this basis. There has been less interest in the prime purpose of such production, which is to increase the accountability and effectiveness of the NHS as a publicly funded service. Rather than working to improve clinical effectiveness and outcomes within clinical services, health authorities which wish to improve outcomes for their populations have been encouraged simply to shift the contract to another provider of care. The key issue on which the ethics of either action rests is the extent to which the attribution of outcome to intervention is valid and reliable and, therefore, that judgements about performance are just and thus ethical. The consequence of unjust judgements may be to increase the inequalities that medical care resource allocation should attempt to reduce.
Inequalities in health: Socioeconomic differences in self-reported morbidity
1990, Public Health
Socioeconomic differences in self-reported chronic and acute illness were investigated in men and women using data from the General Household Surveys (1981–4). Logit models were used to investigate the influence of age, socioeconomic group, tenure, access to cars, area of residence and marital status on these measures of morbidity. For both measures local authority tenants, whether male or female, reported the most morbidity as did those with no access to cars. Both males and females reported increasing levels of illness the lower their socioeconomic group but similar patterns were not observed with acute illness. The significance of these present day inequalities is discussed.
Offspring Socioeconomic Status and Parent Mortality Within a Historical Population
2016, Demography
'The average Scottish man has a cigarette hanging out of his mouth, lying there with a portion of chips': Prospects for change in Scottish men's constructions of masculinity and their health-related beliefs and behaviours
2009, Critical Public Health
Explanations for the age, sex, spatial, and temporal structure of Czech mortality for the period 1987-97
2009, Environment and Planning A

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Regional socioeconomic differences in mortality among men in Great Britain today

Gastroenterology

Journal of Chronic Diseases

Registrar General Scotland

Occupational mortality 1969–73

Occupational mortality Decennial Supplement. England and Wales 1970–72

Occupational mortality Decennial Supplement. England and Wales 1979–80, 82–83

William Farr and the study of occupational mortality

British smoking and drinking habits: regional variations

Community Medicine

Atmospheric pollution and lung cancer

Environmental Health Perspectives

Late effects of air pollution with special reference to Lung Cancer

Environmental Health Perspectives

Lung and Pleura

Smoking and cancer of the lower urinary tract

New England Journal of Medicine

Mortality in relation to smoking: 20 years' observations on male British doctors

British Medical Journal