Abstract
The concept of innateness is a part of folk wisdom but is also used by biologists and cognitive scientists. This concept has a legitimate role to play in science only if the colloquial usage relates to a coherent body of evidence. We examine many different candidates for the post of scientific successor of the folk concept of innateness. We argue that none of these candidates is entirely satisfactory. Some of the candidates are more interesting and useful than others, but the interesting candidates are not equivalent to each other and the empirical and evidential relations between them are far from clear. Researchers have treated the various scientific notions that capture some aspect of the folk concept of innateness as equivalent to each other or at least as tracking properties that are strongly correlated with each other. But whether these correlations exist is an empirical issue. This empirical issue has not been thoroughly investigated because in the attempt to create a bridge between the folk view and their theories, researchers have often assumed that the properties must somehow cluster. Rather than making further attempts to import the folk concept of innateness into the sciences, efforts should now be made to focus on the empirical questions raised by the debates and pave the way to a better way of studying the development of living organisms. Such empirical questions must be answered before it can be decided whether a good scientific successor – in the form of a concept that refers to a collection of biologically significant properties that tend to co-occur – can be identified or whether the concept of innateness deserves no place in science.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
A. Ariew (1996) ArticleTitleInnateness and canalization Phil. Sci. 63 S19–S27
A. Ariew (1999) Innateness is canalization: a defense of a developmental account of innateness V. Hardcastle (Eds) When Biology Meets Psychology MIT Press Cambridge
S. Atran (1990) Cognitive Foundations of Natural History Cambridge University Press Cambridge
S. Atran (1998) ArticleTitleFolk biology and the anthropology of science: cognitive universals and cultural particulars Behav. Brain Sci. 21 547–609
S. Atran D.L. Medin E. Lynch V. Vapnarsky E. Ucan Ek′ P. Sousa (2001) ArticleTitleFolkbiology doesn’t come from folkpsychology: evidence from Yukatec Maya in cross-cultural perspective J. Cogn. Cult. 1 4–42 Occurrence Handle10.1163/156853701300063561
J. Barkow L. Cosmides J. Tooby (1992) The Adapted Mind Oxford University Press Oxford
S. Baron-Cohen (2003) The Essential Difference Norton New York
P. Bateson (1976) ‘Specificity and the origins of behaviour’ J. Rosenblatt R.A. Hinde C. Beer (Eds) Advances in the Study of Behavior NumberInSeriesVol. 6 Academic Press New York 52–81
P. Bateson (1983) Genes, environment and the development of behaviour P. Slater T. Halliday (Eds) Animal Behaviour: Genes, Development and Learning Blackwell Oxford 52–81
P. Bateson (1985) Problems and possibilities in fusing developmental and evolutionary thought G. Butterworth J. Rutowska M. Scaife (Eds) Evolution and Developmental Psychology Harvester Press London
P. Bateson (1991) Are there principles of behavioural development? P. Bateson (Eds) The Development and Integration of Behaviour Cambridge University Press Cambridge
P. Bateson (2000a) What must be known in order to understand imprinting? C. Heyes L. Huber (Eds) The Evolution of Cognition MIT Press Cambridge, MA
P. Bateson (2000b) Taking the stink out of instinct H. Rose S. Rose (Eds) Alas, Poor Darwin Cape London
P. Bateson (2001) Behavioral development and Darwinian evolution S. Oyama P.E. Griffiths R.D. Gray (Eds) Cycles of Contingency: Developmental Systems and Evolution MIT Press Cambridge, MA
P. Bateson (2004a) ArticleTitleThe active role of behaviour in evolution Biol. Phil. 19 283–298
P. Bateson (2004b) ArticleTitleThe origins of human differences Daedalus 133 IssueID4 36–46 Occurrence Handle10.1162/0011526042365636
P. Bateson P. Martin (1999) Design for a Life Cape London
I. Brigandt (2003) ArticleTitleSpecies pluralism does not imply species eliminativism Phil. Sci. 70 IssueID5 1305–1316 Occurrence Handle10.1086/377409
M. Buss David (2003) Evolutionary Psychology: The New Science of the Mind EditionNumber2 Allyn and Bacon Boston
S.E. Carey (1985) Conceptual Change in Childhood MIT Press Cambridge, MA
S.E. Carey R. Gelman (Eds) (1991) The Epigenesis of Mind: Essays on Biology and Cognition Erlbaum Hillsdale, NJ
J. Cassidy (1979) ArticleTitleHalf a century on the concept of innateness and instinct: survey, synthesis and philosophical implications Zeit. Tierpsychol. 50 364–386
N. Chomsky (1959) ArticleTitleA review of B.F. Skinner’s Verbal Behavior Language 35 IssueID1 26–58
N. Chomsky (1965) Aspects of the Theory of Syntax MIT Press Cambridge
N. Chomsky (1972) Language and Mind Harcourt Brace Jovanovich New York
N. Chomsky (1975) Reflections on Language Pantheon Books New York
N. Chomsky (1980) Rules and Representations MIT Press Cambridge, MA
N. Chomsky (1982) Some Concepts and Consequences of the Theory of Government and Binding MIT Press Cambridge, MA
N. Chomsky (1986) Knowledge of Language: Its NatureOrigins, and Use Praeger New York
N. Chomsky (1988) Language and Problems of Knowledge MIT Press Cambridge, MA
N. Chomsky (1993) On the natureuseand acquisition of language A.I. Goldman (Eds) Philosophy and Cognitive Science MIT Press Cambridge, MA
N. Chomsky (2000) On Nature and Language Cambridge University Press Cambridge
F. Cowie (1999) What’s Within: Nativism Reconsidered Oxford University Press Oxford
D. Crews (1996) ArticleTitleTemperature-dependent sex determination: the interplay of steroid hormones and temperature Zool. Sci. 13 1–13
A. Damasio (1994) Descartes’ Error: Emotion, Reason, and the Human Brain Putnam New York
C. Darwin (1859) On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection Murray London
C. Darwin (1871) The Descent of Man and Selection in Relation to Sex Murray London
C. Darwin (1872) The Expression of Emotions in Man and Animals Murray London
R. Dawkins (1982) The Extended Phenotype Oxford Freeman
R. Dawkins (1996) Climbing Mount Improbable Norton New York
A.J. DeCasper M.J. Spence (1986) ArticleTitlePrenatal maternal speech influences newborns’ perception of speech sounds Infant Behav. Dev. 9 133–150 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0163-6383(86)90025-1
I. Eibl-Eibesfeld (1961) The interaction of unlearned behaviour patterns and learning in mammals J.M. Delasfrenaye (Eds) Brain Mechanisms and Learning Blackwell Oxford
J.L. Elman E.A. Bates M.H. Johnson A. Karmiloff-Smith D. Parisi K. Plunkett (1996) Rethinking Innateness MIT Press Cambridge, MA
J.D. Evans D.E. Wheeler (1999) ArticleTitleDifferential gene expression between developing queens and workers in the honey beeApis mellifera Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 96 5575–5580 Occurrence Handle10.1073/pnas.96.10.5575
D.S. Falconer T.F.C. Mackay (1996) Introduction to Quantitative Genetics EditionNumber4 Longmann London
J. Fodor (1981) The present status of the innateness controversy J. Fodor (Eds) Re-Presentations: Philosophical Essays on the Foundations of Cognitive Science MIT Press Cambridge, MA
J. Fodor (2000) The Mind Doesn’t Work That Way MIT Press Cambridge, MA
J. Fodor (2001) ArticleTitleDoing without what’s within Mind 110 99–148 Occurrence Handle10.1093/mind/110.437.99
D.J. Futuyma (1997) Evolutionary Biology Sinauer Sunderland, MA
E.M. Gander (2003) On Our Minds Johns Hopkins Baltimore
S.F. Gilbert (2001) ArticleTitleEcological developmental biology: developmental biology meets the real world Dev. Biol. 233 1–12 Occurrence Handle10.1006/dbio.2001.0210
S.F. Gilbert (2002) Canalization M. Pagel (Eds) Encyclopedia of Evolution Oxford University Press Oxford
S.F. Gilbert (2003a) The reactive genome G.B. Muller S.A. Newman (Eds) Origination of Organismal Form: Beyond the Gene in Developmental and Evolutionary Biology MIT Press Cambridge, MA
S.F. Gilbert (2003b) ArticleTitleEvo-devodevo-evoand devgen-popgene Biol. Phil. 18 347–352
S.F. Gilbert (2003c) Developmental Biology EditionNumber7 Sinauer Sunderland, MA
P. Godfrey-Smith (1999) Genes and codes: lessons from the philosophy of mind? V. Hardcastle (Eds) Where Biology Meets Psychology MIT Press Cambridge, MA
P. Godfrey-Smith (2000) ArticleTitleOn the theoretical role of “genetic coding” Phil. Sci. 67 26–44
G. Gottlieb (1992) Individual Development and Evolution Oxford University Press New York
G. Gottlieb (1997) Synthesizing Nature-Nurture Lawrence Erlbaum Mahwah, NJ
G. Gottlieb (2003a) Behavioral development and evolution B.K. Hall W.M. Olson (Eds) Keywords and Concepts in Evolutionary Developmental Biology Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA
G. Gottlieb (2003b) ArticleTitleOn making behavioral genetics truly developmental Hum. Dev. 46 337–355
R.D. Gray (1992) Death of the gene: developmental systems strike back P.E. Griffiths (Eds) Trees of Life: Essays on the Philosophy of Biology Kluwer Dordrecht
R.D. Gray (2001) Selfish genes or developmental systems? R. Singh K. Krimbas D.D. Paul J. Beatty (Eds) Thinking about Evolution Cambridge University Press Cambridge
P.E. Griffiths (1997) What Emotions Really Are University of Chicago Press Chicago
P.E. Griffiths (2001) ArticleTitleGenetic information: a metaphor in search of a theory Phil. Sci. 68 394–412 Occurrence Handle10.1086/392891
P.E. Griffiths (2002) ArticleTitleWhat is innateness? Monist 85 70–85
P.E. Griffiths (2004) ArticleTitleInstinct in the ‘850s: the British reception of Konrad Lorenz’s theory of instinctive behaviour Biol. Phil. 19 IssueID4 609–631
Griffths P.E. forthcoming. The fearless vampire conservator: Philip Kitcher, genetic determinism and the informational genes. In: Neumann-Held E. and Rehmann-Sutter C. (eds), Genes in Development: Rereading the Molecular Paradigm. Duke University Press, Durham, NC.
P.E. Griffiths R.D. Gray (1994) ArticleTitleDevelopmental systems and evolutionary explanation J. Phil. 91 277–304
P.E. Griffiths R.D. Gray (1997) ArticleTitleReplicator II: judgement day Biol. Phil. 12 471–492
P.E. Griffiths R.D. Gray (2001) Darwinism and developmental systems S. Oyama P.E. Griffiths R.D. Gray (Eds) Cycles of Contingency: Developmental Systems and Evolution MIT Press Cambridge, MA
B. Hallgrimsson (2002) Developmental stability M. Pagel (Eds) Encyclopedia of Evolution Oxford University Press Oxford
D.O. Hebb (1953) ArticleTitleHeredity and environment in animal behaviour Br. J. Anim. Behav. 1 43–47
R. Herrnstein C. Murray (1994) The Bell Curve: Intelligence and Class Structure in American Life The Free Press New York
C. Heyes (2000) Evolutionary psychology in the round C. Heyes L. Huber (Eds) The Evolution of Cognition MIT Press Cambridge, MA
C. Heyes (2003) ArticleTitleFour routes of cognitive evolution Psychol. Rev. 110 713–727
R.A. Hinde (1966) Animal Behavior: A Synthesis of Ethology and Comparative Psychology McGraw Hill New York
J.A. Hogan (1994) The concept of cause in the study of behavior J.A. Hogan J.J. Bolhuis (Eds) Causal Mechanisms of Behavioural Development Cambridge University Press Cambridge
J.A. Hogan (2001) Development of behavior systems E.M. Blass (Eds) Handbook of Behavioral Neurobiology NumberInSeriesVol. 13 Kluwer Academic Publishers New York
J. Jacobs (1981) ArticleTitleHow heritable is innate behaviour? Zeit. Tierpsychol. 55 1–18
F.J. Janzen G.L. Paukstis (1991) ArticleTitleEnvironmental sex determination in reptiles: ecology, evolution, and experimental design Quart. Rev. Biol. 66 149–179 Occurrence Handle10.1086/417143
D.D. Jensen (1961) ArticleTitleOperationalism and the question ‘Is this behavior learned or innate?’ Behaviour 17 1–8
A.R. Jensen (1969) ArticleTitleHow much can we boost IQ and scholastic achievement? Har. Edu. Rev. 19 1–123
T.D. Johnston (2001) Towards a systems view of development: an appraisal of Lehrman’s critique of Lonrenz S. Oyama P.E. Griffiths R.D. Gray (Eds) Cycles of Contingency: Developmental Systems and Evolution MIT Press Cambridge, MA
M.A. Khalidi (2002) ArticleTitleNature and nurture in cognition Br. J. Phil. Sci. 53 251–272
D.S. Lehrman (1953) ArticleTitleA critique of Konrad Lorenz’s theory of instinctive behavior Quart. Rev. Biol. 28 337–363 Occurrence Handle10.1086/399858
D.S. Lehrman (1970) Semantic and conceptual issues in the nature-nurture problem L. Aronson E. Tobech D.S. Lehiman J. Rosenblatt (Eds) et al. Development and Evolution of Behavior Freeman San Francisco
R.C. Lewontin (1974) ArticleTitleThe analysis of variance and the analysis of causes Am. J. Hum. Genet. 26 400–411
R.C. Lewontin (2000) The Triple Helix: GeneOrganism and Environment Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA
K. Lorenz (1937) ArticleTitleUber den Begriff der Instinkthandlung Folia Biotheor. 2 17–50
K. Lorenz (1939) ArticleTitleVergleichende Verhaltensforschung Zool. Anzeit. 12(Suppl. band.) 69–102
K. Lorenz (1965) Evolution and Modification of Behavior Meuthen London
M. Lynch B. Walsh (1997) Genetics and Analysis of Quantitative Traits Sinauer Sunderland, MA
M. Mameli (2004) ArticleTitleNongenetic selection and nongenetic inheritance Br. J. Phil. Sci. 55 35–71
M. Mameli (2005) ArticleTitleThe inheritance of features Phil. Biol. 20 365–399
Mameli M. and Papineau P. 2005. The new nativism: a commentary on Marcus’s The Birth of the Mind. Biol. Phil.
G. Marcus (2003) The Birth of the Mind Basic Books New York
P. Marler (2004) ArticleTitleInnateness and the instinct to learn Anais Acad. Brasil. Cien. 76 IssueID2 189–200
G.F. Miller (2000) The Mating Mind: How Sexual Choice Shaped the Evolution of Human Nature Doubleday New York
D.L. Medin S. Atran (Eds) (1999) Folkbiology MIT Press Cambridge, MA
J. Maynard Smith (2000) ArticleTitleThe concept of information in biology Phil. Sci. 62 177–194
M. Meaney (2003) ArticleTitleNaturenurtureand the disunity of science Ann. N Y Acad. Sci. 935 50–61
D.S. Moore (2001) The Dependent Gene: The Fallacy of “Nature vs. Nurture” Holt and Company New York
S. Pinker (1998) How the Mind Works Norton New York
S. Pinker (2002) The Blank Slate Viking Pengium New York
Pinker S. 2004. Why nature and nurture won’t go away. Daedalus 133(4): 5–17.
H.C. Plotkin (1997) Evolution in Mind: An Introduction to Evolutionary Psychology Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA
S.R. Quartz (1999) ArticleTitleThe constructivist brain Trends Cogn. Sci. 3 48–57 Occurrence Handle10.1016/S1364-6613(98)01270-4
S.R. Quartz T.J. Sejnowski (1997) ArticleTitleThe neural basis of cognitive development: a constructivist manifesto Behav. Brain Sci. 20 537–596
A. Rachinsky K. Hartfelder (1990) ArticleTitleCorpora allata activity, aprime regulating element for caste-specific juvenile hormone titre in honey bee larvae (Apis mellifera carnica) J. Insect Physiol. 36 189–194 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0022-1910(90)90121-U
W.J. Rowland P. Sevenster (1985) ArticleTitleSign stimuli in sticklebacks: are-examination and extension of some classic experiments Behaviour 93 241–257
M. Ridley (2003) Evolution Oxford Blackwell
R. Samuels (1998) ArticleTitleWhat brains won’t tell us about the mind: a critique of the neurobiological argument against representational nativism Mind Lang. 13 548–570 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1468-0017.00091
R. Samuels (2002) ArticleTitleNativism in cognitive science Mind Lang. 17 233–265 Occurrence Handle10.1111/1468-0017.00197
R. Samuels (2004) ArticleTitleInnateness in cognitive science Trends Cogn. Sci. 8 136–141 Occurrence Handle10.1016/j.tics.2004.01.010
T.C. Schneirla (1956) The interrelationship of ‘innate’ and ‘acquired’ in instinctive behavior P.P. Grasse (Eds) L’instinct dans le comportement des animaux et de l’homme Masson Paris
E. Sober (1984) The Nature of Selection MIT Press Cambridge, MA
E. Sober (2001) Philosophy of Biology Boulder Westview
K. Sterelny (2000) ArticleTitleThe “genetic program” program: a commentary on Maynard Smith on information in biology Phil. Sci. 67 195–201 Occurrence Handle10.1086/392769
K. Sterelny (2001) Niche construction, developmental systems, and the extended replicator S. Oyama P.E. Griffiths R.D. Gray (Eds) Cycles of Contingency: Developmental Systems and Evolution MIT Press Cambridge, MA
K. Sterelny (2003) Thought in a Hostile World Oxford Blackwell
K. Sterelny (2004) Symbiosis, evolvability and modularity G. Schlosser G. Wagner (Eds) Modularity in Development and Evolution University of Chicago Press Chicago
K. Sterelny P.S. Kitcher (1988) ArticleTitleThe return of the gene J. Phil. 85 335–358
K. Sterelny K. Smith M. Dickison (1996) ArticleTitleThe extended replicator Biol. Phil. 11 377–403
M.J. Spence A.J. DeCasper (1987) ArticleTitlePrenatal experience with low-frequency maternal voice sounds influences neonatal perception of maternal voice samples Infant Behav. Dev. 10 133–142 Occurrence Handle10.1016/0163-6383(87)90028-2
D. Symons (1992) On the use and misuse of Darwinism in the study of human behavior J.H. Barkow L. Cosmides J. Tooby (Eds) The Adapted Mind Oxford University Press Oxford
N. Tinbergen (1951) The Study of Instinct Clarendon Press Oxford
N. Tinbergen (1955) Psychology and ethology as supplementary parts of a science of behaviour B. Schaffner (Eds) Group Processes Josiah Macy Jr. Foundation New York
N. Tinbergen (1963) ArticleTitleOn aims and methods of ethology Zeit. Tierpsychol. 20 404–433
J. Tooby L. Cosmides (1990a) ArticleTitleOn the universality of human nature and the uniqueness of the individual: the role of genetics and adaptation J. Personal. 58 17–67
J. Tooby L. Cosmides (1990b) ArticleTitleThe past explains the present: emotional adaptations and the structure of ancestral environments Ethol. Sociobiol. 11 375–424
J. Tooby L. Cosmides (1992) The psychological foundations of culture J. Barkow L. Cosmides J. Tooby (Eds) The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture Oxford University Press New York
C. Weele Particlevan der (1999) Images of Development: Environmental Causes in Ontogeny Suny Press Albany NY
C.H. Waddington (1957) The Strategy of the Gene Routledge London
C.H. Waddington (1975) The Evolution of an Evolutionist Cornell University Press Ithaca
M.J. West-Eberhard (2003) Developmental Plasticity and Evolution Oxford University Press Oxford
A. Wilkins (2003) Canalization and genetic assimilation B.K. Hall W.M. Olson (Eds) Keywords and Concepts in Evolutionary Developmental Biology Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA
R.A. Wilson (2005) Genes and the Agents of Life Cambridge University Press Cambridge
Wimsatt W. 1986. Developmental constraints, generative entrenchment, and the innate acquired distinction. In: Bechtel W. (ed.), Integrating Scientific Disciplines. Martinus-Nijhoff.
W.C. Wimsatt (1999) Generativity, entrenchmentevolution, and innateness: philosophy, evolutionary biology, and conceptual foundations of science V. Hardcastle (Eds) When Biology Meets Psychology MIT Press Cambridge
R. Wright (1997) The Moral Animal Peter Smith London
C.L. Yntema N. Mrosovsky (1982) ArticleTitleCritical periods and pivotal temperatures for sexual differentiation in loggerhead sea turtles Can. J. Zool. 60 1012–1016
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mameli, M., Bateson, P. Innateness and the Sciences. Biol Philos 21, 155–188 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-005-5144-0
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10539-005-5144-0