Table 3

Assessing covariate balance before and after matching using two-sample t-tests

USA (NHIS 2003–2014)Canada (CCHS 2003–2014)
EmployedUnemployedEmployedUnemployed
UnmatchedCalliperKernelUnmatchedCalliperKernelUnmatchedCalliperKernelUnmatchedCalliperKernel
Age (years)−4.34***−0.36−0.37−5.58***−0.17−0.850.17−1.75−0.412.28*−1.01−0.05
Female10.89***−0.880.298.41***−1.390.155.30***−0.25−0.55−1.54−0.22−0.43
Household type
 Single−11.71***0.44−0.458.11***−0.030.715.41***−0.260.2
 Couple−22.90***0.14−1.45−7.41***−0.51−0.38−8.01***−0.99−0.3−3.63***0.15−0.08
 Single with children21.08***−0.630.2615.59***−1.170.2315.33***0.980.014.90***00.04
 Couple with children5.25***0.550.723.41***1.170.26−16.61***−0.58−0.81−10.02***0.27−0.3
Number of children (0–18 years old)17.54***−0.32−0.0615.14***0.040.06
Number of children (0–5 years old)1.52−0.350.133.20**1.80.16
Number of children (6–11 years old)0.83−0.25−0.612.65**0.780.3
Race
 White−7.30***−0.65−0.34−6.42***0.35−0.334.05***−1.89−0.053.33**0.21−0.04
 Black7.57***−0.83−0.015.91***0.47−0.09
 Aboriginal1.81−0.580.390.80.50.059.73***1.360.244.20***−1.49−0.91
 Asian−3.96***0.33−0.92−1.52−1.110.27
 Hispanic1.931.070.291.05−0.50.27
 Other or mixed2.98**2.15*1.27−0.7100.15−10.86***1.150.2−7.55***1.31.03
Immigrant4.160.25−0.193.46***0.360.07−12.98***0.78−0.33−8.43***1.661.31
Education
 Postsecondary degree−8.24***−1.2−0.84−4.59***0−0.48−10.83***0.55−0.2−8.60***−1.7−0.36
 Some postsecondary−0.092.13*0.73−1.221.020.4−1.96−1.61−1.281.17−0.58−0.86
 Secondary0.1−1.7−0.63−1.18−0.19−0.32−1.910.69−3.13**1.020.55
 Less than secondary5.58***0.090.234.84***−0.710.1112.94***0.430.737.69***0.620.54
Adjusted household income−1.49−1.67−0.81−4.10***−0.27−0.19
Urban3.01**−0.050.15−0.37−0.44−0.55
Health insurance coverage10.15***−0.340.2915.33***0.620.38
Home owner−9.49***0.38−0.31−7.53***0.11−0.37−29.42***0.96−0.28−17.31***0.590.31
Part-time employment5.93***0.54−0.1325.60***0.480.79
Mental health problem5.13***−1.22−0.411.160.640.1318.58***0.260.225.87***−0.89−0.4
Region
 Northeast (USA)/Atlantic (CA)3.56***1.360.135.65***−1.360.155.41***0.660.532.70**−0.47−0.11
 Midwest (USA)/Prairies (CA)0.64−0.430.021.880.4−0.56−4.81***2.99**0.12−1.14−0.44−0.67
 South (USA)/Quebec (CA)−11.20***−1.09−0.51−10.50***−0.07−0.355.66***−1.360.28.40***−0.311.24
 West (USA)/Ontario (CA)9.16***0.320.335.68***0.880.7−0.97−0.81−0.64−4.23***0.97−0.93
 British Columbia (CA)−3.89***−1.04−0.04−6.34***0.060.34
  • *p<0.05, **p<0.01, ***p<0.001.

  • NHIS,   National Health Interview Survey; CCHS, Canadian Community Health Survey.