28 e-Letters

published between 2011 and 2014

  • Self-reported passive smoking and salivary cotinine concentration
    Tomoyuki Kawada

    Batty et al. conducted a follow-up study to know the effect of passive smoking on subsequent mortality [1]. In men in their study, self- reported passive smoking, not salivary cotinine, could predict mortality. From their Tables 1 and 2, salivary cotinine level was categorized into three groups, and self-reported passive smoking was categorized binary. I have a query on the association between self-reported passive smokin...

    Show More
  • Re:Extreme temperatures and paediatric emergency
    Zhiwei Xu

    Dear Sir, Thank you very much for your interest in our research. In our JECH paper, we analyzed data on a broad range of pediatric diseases and found, generally, children aged 10-14 years are more vulnerable to both hot and cold effects, compared with children of other age groups. In the OEM paper, we analyzed pediatric asthma data and found, specifically, children aged 10-14 years are more sensitive to the adverse impact...

    Show More
  • Trajectories for each cohort need to span the same/ similar age range
    William Johnson

    The three cohorts in this study were as follows:

    Cohort 1: born 1970s and followed between ~15-35 years of age

    Cohort 2: born 1950s and followed between ~35-55 years of age

    Cohort 3: born 1930s and followed between ~55-75 years of age

    This study design has serious limitations for the investigation of cohort differences in BMI trajectories (and therefore also for the investigation of...

    Show More
  • Is 7 a day really better than 5 a day?
    Robert J Hancox

    These impressive data have been widely reported. Eating plenty of fruit and vegetables seems to be a good idea, but I am concerned at how the need to eat 7+ portions a day to obtain maximum benefit has been reported. As far as I can tell, the estimates for "daily" consumption were based on a single day. Few people eat exactly the same every day and regression to the mean suggests that most of those who ate 7+ portions on...

    Show More
  • Re:What exactly is a vegetable?
    Oyinlola Oyebode

    Dear Prof. Bland,

    Please see our supplementary material where you can see the questions that were asked during the interview. You will note that survey participants were explicitly advised not to include potatoes when considering their answers.

    http://jech.bmj.com/content/suppl/2014/03/04/jech-2013- 203500.DC1/jech-2013-203500supp1.pdf

    Conflict of Interest:


    Show More
  • Air pollution and respiratory symptoms in children
    Tomoyuki Kawada

    Molter et al. reported the effects of long-term exposure to particulate matter with aerodynamic diameter <10 micrometer (PM10) and nitrogen dioxide (NO2) on the prevalence of asthma and wheeze within a population-based birth cohort (1). They concluded that no significant association between long-term exposure to PM10 and NO2 and the prevalence of either asthma or wheeze was found. In contrast, the same authors report...

    Show More
  • What exactly is a vegetable?
    John M Bland

    I may have missed it, but Oyebode et al. do not seem to say exactly what they mean by a vegetable or what the exact question was. This is important, because they do refer to a UK Department of Health website, which states that potatoes, yams, plantain, and casava should not be included the 5-a-day count, but sweetcorn should. I thought that sweetcorn was a grain and so would not count it as a vegetable, though I may b...

    Show More
  • Extreme temperatures and paediatric emergency
    Viroj Wiwanitkit

    Sir, the recent report on "extreme temperatures and paediatric emergency" is very interesting [1]. Xu et al. concluded that "children are at particular risk of a variety of diseases which might be triggered by extremely high temperatures [1]."Xu et al. also mentioned for the effect of climate change. In fact, Xu et al. reported a highly similar publication in Occup Environ Med and also noted for the effect of climate chan...

    Show More
  • Re: Social determinants of mental health: a Finnish nationwide follow up study on mental disorders
    Narjes Hazar

    Dear Editor, The published paper by Paananen et al, entitled "Social determinants of mental health: a Finnish nationwide follow up study on mental disorders"1 was an interesting and rigorous study. Through a longitudinal approach, all Finnish children who were born in a certain year (1987) were followed through adolescence in order to examine the development of mental disorders and assess potential SDH-related risk fact...

    Show More
  • Cochrane review of health & socio-economic impacts of housing improvement
    Hilary Thomson

    This is a great contribution to the literature on fuel poverty, cold housing, and health.

    The authors call for a review of qualitative and intervention research related to this topic. It may be useful for readers to be made aware of a recently updated version of a systematic review of the health and socio-economic impacts of housing improvement published by the Campbell and Cochrane Collaborations 1. In this revi...

    Show More