Article Text

Download PDFPDF
  1. Brandace Winquist,
  2. Nazeem Muhajarine
  1. Department of Community Health and Epidemiology, College of Medicine, University of Saskatchewan


Introduction New prenatal screening technologies have made it possible for a simple blood test to assist in the identification of several conditions in the fetus early in pregnancy. Given more information about the health status of the fetus, women are able to make decisions about whether to continue or terminate pregnancies affected by congenital anomalies. The reasons for choosing to screen or not to screen are as complex as each individual, but also depend on cultural, programmatic and system-level factors. As such, rates of uptake of prenatal screening vary widely by geographic location, and correlate to client and physician characteristics and value systems.

The Saskatchewan Maternal Serum Screening (MSS) programme was implemented in 2001 offering the ‘triple marker screen’, but uptake has been consistently low when compared with other jurisdictions. For instance, in 2006, screening uptake was 63% in Ontario, 60% in Manitoba, 49% in British Columbia and 25% in Saskatchewan. Studies from other countries have shown that personal characteristics, such as maternal age, religious background, ethnicity and geographic location all predict MSS use to some extent. However, it is not known if similar factors influence the decision-making capacity of pregnant women in Canada. There is the perception by some Saskatchewan physicians that aboriginal women in the province accept MSS less often than non-aboriginal women. This is the first study in Canada to conduct a detailed exploration of the predictors of MSS uptake, while controlling for other covariates.

Objectives To explore variations in utilisation of prenatal screening according to mothers' geographic location, ethnicity and age.

Methods A 3-year subset (2002–2004) of a larger population-based, prospective, cohort study was used for the current analysis. Data were drawn from multiple sources, including Saskatchewan's administrative databases (hospital and physician billing), vital statistics, a provincial laboratory MSS data file, and cytogenetic laboratory data from the Saskatoon and Regina Qu'Appelle Health Regions. Pregnancies resulting in a live or stillbirth, or those that were terminated for congenital anomaly, were included in the current analysis, while elective medical or spontaneous abortions were excluded. χ2 Analysis was used to determine which variables to include in the multivariate model. Using Hosmer and Lemeshow's model building strategy, binary logistic regression was used to explore differences between women who had MSS and those who did not.

Results A total of 35 515 pregnancies were included in analysis. Over the 3-year period, MSS uptake in Saskatchewan increased slightly from 21.2% to 25.8% of all births. Health region of residence, age group, registered Indian status, and year of MSS test were all significant predictors (p<0.001) for MSS. Significant interaction effects were found between age group and health region of residence (p<0.001), age group and registered Indian status (p=0.02), and health region of residence and registered Indian status (p=0.004).

Conclusions The likelihood that women will have MSS increases with age; a gradient observed also for First Nations and rural women. However, screening rates were much lower in First Nations (compared with non-First Nations), and rural women (compared with urban) for all age groups considered. Interestingly, First Nations women living in an urban health region were more likely to screen than First Nations women living in a rural health region. Lower screening rates in First Nations and rural populations may reflect differences in personal value systems and/or in the way prenatal care is accessed and delivered. Differential uptake across populations is important to understand, because in some cases, MSS precipitates the termination of pregnancies affected by a congenital anomaly; a practice that has the potential to lower congenital anomaly prevalence and the infant mortality rate differentially across groups.

Statistics from

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.