Cross-cultural differences in driver risk-perception

doi:10.1016/0001-4575(89)90026-2

Accident Analysis & Prevention

Volume 21, Issue 4, August 1989, Pages 355-362

https://doi.org/10.1016/0001-4575(89)90026-2 Get rights and content

Abstract

This study investigated differences in risk-perception among U.S., Spanish, West German, and Brazilian drivers. Subjects estimated the risk involved in slide-projected traffic scenes. The scenes, photographed in the United States and Spain, were rated for the amount of risk by using a seven-point scale. The subject groups in each country included younger, middle-aged, and older nonprofessional drivers, as well as middle-aged professional (bus, taxi, or truck) drivers. In the data analyses, the independent variables were subjects' country, age, professional driving experience, and sex, and 23 dichotomously coded characteristics of the traffic scenes. The following are the main findings: (1) Spanish drivers reported the highest risk, while U.S. drivers reported the lowest risk; (2) younger drivers tended to report lower risk than middle-aged and older drivers; (3) nineteen of the 23 analysed characteristics of traffic scenes contributed significantly to risk ratings, even after simultaneously controlling for the effects of all other scene characteristics; (4) ten scene characteristics had a differential effect on the risk ratings in the four tested countries; (5) two scene characteristics had a differential effect on the risk ratings in the four tested subject groups; (6) none of the variables affected differentially the risk ratings of professional vs. nonprofessional drivers and males vs. females. These findings provide information concerning the desirable country- and age-specific emphasis in driver education, driver licensing, and public information campaigns.

References (8)

P. Finn et al.
Perception of the risk of an accident by young and older drivers
Accid. Anal. Prev.
(1986)
M.L. Matthews et al.
Age differences in male drivers' perception of accident risk: The role of perceived driving ability
Accid. Anal. Prev.
(1986)
M. Sivak et al.
Cross-cultural differences in driver risk-taking
Accid. Anal. Prev.
(1989)
M. Sivak et al.
Cross-cultural differences in driver self-assessment
Accid. Anal. Prev.
(1989)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (77)

Modeling traveler's speed-route joint choice behavior with heterogeneous safety concern
2023, Analytic Methods in Accident Research
In this study, a speed-route joint choice model considering traveler’s safety concerns is proposed to concurrently model traveler’s safety-oriented travel speed and route choice behavior. Specifically, the safe-speed choice behavior is modeled as a trade-off process between perceived traffic safety and efficiency using a disutility function. The safe-route choice behavior is described by the proposed Mean-excess Crash Risk Cost model, where the route safety is modeled as a random variable following a specific distribution, and traveler’s concerns about both reliability and unreliability aspects of safety variability are considered. The model is accommodative to account for the random nature and the traveler’s perception of traffic safety. Also, the travel time cost is considered, which is depicted as a parallel criterion of travel safety in the route choice model. Moreover, the heterogeneities of travelers’ safety concerns in both the choices of speed and route are considered in the proposed joint model. Then, the study formulated the equilibrium problem with the two behavior elements (speed and route) and two choice criteria (safety and time), based on the assumption that all travelers tend to maximize their disutility when choosing speed while minimizing their travel safety variability and travel time. To illustrate the model, Nguyen and Dupuis, Sioux falls, and Changsha arterial networks are conducted as numerical studies. The result demonstrates the model’s capability in depicting travelers’ trade-off between safety and time when selecting the optimal travel speed. Considering the impact of route safety unreliability makes the model sensible to describe travelers’ safety-concerned route choice behavior. The model is also flexible to account for travelers’ crash risk aversion heterogeneity.
The influence of fatalistic beliefs and risk perceptions on road safety attitudes in Latin America; A two-country study
2022, Transportation Research Part F: Traffic Psychology and Behaviour
Road safety is a major challenge in the Latin American region; however, there is a significant lack of research undertaken there. To contribute to addressing this gap, this paper reports on an exploration of the antecedents of traffic safety attitudes in two Latin American contexts: Brazil and Ecuador. Building on related work undertaken in other countries, the research explored the relationships between fatalistic beliefs, traffic risk perceptions, and road safety attitudes, while accounting for age, gender, and exposure to the road environment. Data from 2432 individuals, analysed using Structural Equation Modelling, revealed differences in the extent to which different fatalistic belief constructs (including divine control, luck, helplessness, internality, and general fatalism) were related to road safety attitudes. Moreover, fatalistic beliefs were found to influence road safety attitudes both directly and indirectly through their influence on risk perceptions. Those that reported more fatalistic beliefs also reported more dangerous attitudes to road safety and a lower perception of on-road risk. Mirroring findings from work undertaken in other countries, we found males compared to females and younger compared to older respondents to report more dangerous attitudes to road safety, with inconclusive results for risk perceptions. We also found very similar patterns of results in the data from the two countries included in the research. Results are discussed with regards to informing the design of road safety interventions aimed at influencing individual road user attitudes and, ultimately, human behaviour and system performance.
The development of safe riding guidelines for young riders – A case study of Phu Yen, Vietnam
2021, IATSS Research
Phu Yen is a small province located in the central part of Vietnam and is suffering from a tremendous number of traffic casualties, compared with other cities in Vietnam and developed countries. Young riders take a large proportion, accounting for 47.6% in total traffic crashes. To resolve this issue, the present study aims to (i) analyze young riders' behavior and their attitudes towards traffic safety and to (ii) propose a procedure to develop a book of safe riding guidelines to reduce their involvement in dangerous situations. A set of 73 questions in the questionnaire survey have been conducted to determine the risk-taking behavior and attitude towards traffic safety of 300 individuals, who are using bicycles, e-bikes, mopeds, scooters, and motorcycles less than 150 cc. The statistical results indicate that there are significant differences among riding behavior and attitudes of respondents towards traffic safety regarding the regional factor (rural, suburb, and urban), the demographic factor (gender and age), and the travel distance factor. The guidelines designed based on the questionnaire survey are used to alter adolescents' riding behavior and attitudes and so help them recognize, avoid, and handle risks in demanding traffic situations. An analysis of the before and after the traffic safety training workshop to evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed guidelines indicated that there was a significant increment in the perceived risks of young riders after training them by using this book.
The extended theory of planned behavior considering heterogeneity under a connected vehicle environment: A case of uncontrolled non-signalized intersections
2021, Accident Analysis and Prevention
Citation Excerpt :
Risk perceptions of high-neurotic drivers if they have an acceleration through an uncontrolled non-signalized intersection with the provision of real-time information by CV technology, are related to age and annual driving mileage, while that of low-neurotic drivers are not. More specifically, different from experienced low-neurotic drivers, experienced high-neurotic drivers have a high risk perception of such a situation, which is consistent with Sivak et al. (1989) and Nordfjrn and Rundmo (2009). This also can be explained by Ulleberg and Rundmo (2003) and Machin and Sankey (2008), who found that experienced high-neurotic drivers understand their inclination to have negative emotions, such as anger and hostility, and these emotions have a strong relationship to take a risky situation, hence, they are concern and worry of being injured and hurting others.
With the emergence of connected vehicle (CV) technology, there is a doubt whether CVs can improve driver intentions and behaviors, and thus protect them from accidents with the provision of real-time information. In order to understand the possible impacts of the real-time information provided by CV technology on drivers, this paper aims to develop a model which considers the heterogeneity between drivers with the aid of the extended theory of planned behavior. At the uncontrolled non-signalized intersections, a stated preference (SP) questionnaire survey was conducted to build the dataset consisting of 1001 drivers. Based on the collected dataset, the proposed model examines the relationships between subjective norms, attitudes, risk perceptions, perceived behavioral control and driving intentions, and studies how such driving intentions are simultaneously related to driver characteristics and experiences in the CV environment. Furthermore, driver groups which are homogenous with respect to personality traits are formed, and then are employed to analyze the heterogeneity in responses to driving intentions. Four key findings are obtained when analyzing driver responses to the real-time information provided by CV technology: 1) the proposed H-ETPB model is verified with a good fitness measure; 2) irrespective to driver personality traits, attitudes and perceived behavioral control have a direct and indirect association with driving intentions to accelerate; 3) driving intentions of high-neurotic drivers to accelerate are significantly related to subjective norms, while that of low-neurotic drivers are not; 4) elder high-neurotic drivers, and low-neurotic drivers who have unstable salaries or ever joined in online car hailing service have a strong intention in accelerating. The findings of this study could provide the theoretical framework to optimize traffic performance and information design, as well as provide in-vehicle personalized information service in the CV and CAV environments and assist traffic authorities to design the most acceptable traffic rules for different drivers at an uncontrolled non-signalized intersection.
Risk Perception in Transport: A Review of the State of the Art
2021, International Encyclopedia of Transportation: Volume 1-7
The aim of this chapter is to provide an overview of the state of the art concerning the role of transport risk perception for driving behavior, demand for risk mitigation and use of sustainable urban transport modes. The chapter also discusses the risk perception concept with a focus on operational definition and theoretical foundations. The review shows that risk perception may be relevant for all three transport outcomes. The research field could benefit from a more restricted understanding of risk perception as a pure cognitive construct covering perceived probability and severity of consequences of negative events aligned with theoretical approaches to risk. Future research could focus on harmonizing the operational definition of risk perception and aim to investigate which of the two main components are more important for transport behavior. Their associations with related, albeit separated, risk judgments and emotional processes also need to be disentangled.
A cross-cultural comparison of visual search strategies and response times in road hazard perception testing
2020, Accident Analysis and Prevention
Road hazard perception is considered the most prominent higher-order cognitive skill related to traffic-accident involvement. Regional cultures and social rules that govern acceptable behavior may influence drivers’ interpretation of a traffic situation and, consequently, the correct identification of potentially hazardous situations. Here, we aimed to compare hazard perception skills among four European countries that differ in their traffic culture, policies to reduce traffic risks, and fatal crashes: Ukraine, Italy, Spain, and Sweden. We developed a static hazard perception test in which driving scenes with different levels of braking affordance were presented while drivers’ gaze was recorded. The test required drivers to indicate the action they would undertake: to brake vs. to keep driving. We assessed 218 young adult drivers. Multilevel models revealed that the scenes’ levels of braking affordance (i.e., road hazard) modulated drivers’ behavior. As the levels of braking affordance increased, drivers’ responses became faster and their gaze entropy decreased (i.e., visual search strategy became less erratic). The country of origin influenced these effects. Ukrainian drivers were the fastest and Swedish drivers were the slowest to respond. For all countries, the decrement in response times was less marked in the case of experienced drivers. Also, Spanish drivers showed the most structured (least erratic) visual search strategy, whereas the Italians had the most rigid (most constant) one. These results suggest that road hazard perception can be defined cross-culturally, with cultural factors (e.g., traffic climate, legislation) modulating response times and visual search strategies. Our results also support the idea that a multimodal assessment methodology is possible for mass testing of road hazard perception and its outcomes would be relevant to understand how different traffic cultures shape driving behavior.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

Cross-cultural differences in driver risk-perception

Abstract

Accid. Anal. Prev.

Accid. Anal. Prev.

Accid. Anal. Prev.

Accid. Anal. Prev.