Table 3

 Summary of health impacts in the social and economic category of health determinants

Category of influencePositive impactsCommunity plan theme groups linked to each impact
Abbreviations as in table 1.
Social, cultural and economic, enterprise and business links, community participation, peer pressure• Direct employment during both phases of economic regeneration potentials.EP
• Provided a range of employment across Salford’s communitiesEP, SCI
• Benefits of business and supply links with the local Salford economyEP
• Increased community activities through community cafes bring people of all ages together.SCI, SFC, LC
• The project attracts inward investments and enhances the attractiveness of Salford and the city is seen as a good place for a career by professionalSG
• Enhanced culture and prestige through a reduction in social exclusion, stress through education leading to improved job opportunities.SCI, VC
• Enhanced life chances of disadvantaged community groupsSCI
• Peer pressure reduced due to active involvement with the project and as quality of life improves, youth crime and antisocial behaviour are reduced.SC, SFC
• Uplift, feelings of esteem, and increased pride in the communities as local people take up professional careers with SHIFT and LIFT.SFC, EP
• Social networks improve to enhance the opportunities for community inclusionSFC, SCI
• Business links provide the opportunity to develop community enterprises and social businesses.EP
• The local economy develops as SHIFT and LIFT use and help to develop local supply chains.EP, SFC
• Opportunity to develop networks and community participation.SFC
• Addressed inequalities and promote inclusion of Salford’s community groups and peoplesSCI, VC
Negative impacts
• Decreased trade for local shops and businesses during the development phase that do not recover during the operational phase.EP
• Low entrepreneurial esteem and increased dependency as local business and supply links are not realised.EP
• Without necessary education and training the gap between the skills available and those required in both the NHS and the commercial sector in Salford continue to widen.EP
• Anger, frustration, and resentment from the disruption to communities creates social isolation.SCI
• Reinforced feeling of low self esteem and psychological wellbeing because of lack of engagement between SHIFT and LIFT and local communities.EP, SG, SCI
• Social exclusion of minority groups.EP
• Lip service paid and the services promised by the project are not realised.EP, SG
• Lack of facilities from the project encourages unsocial behaviour.SFC
• Community members are frightened of reporting crime.SFC
• An unsympathetic Trust leads to frustration in the communities.SG
• The project does not involve communities in crime prevention.SFC
• Breakdown in social interaction around the centres as families do not visit because of poor access.SFC, EP
• Local people continue to feel that they do not get feedback from consultations.SFC, SG
• No access to GPs in the evening after work.SG